e.preventDefault(); // stop navigation
While reviewing hundreds of Reddit car shipping discussions and Better Business Bureau (BBB) complaints, we started noticing the same problems coming up again and again.
This article walks through the 10 most common auto transport mistakes we found across those real customer experiences, explains why they keep happening, and what you can do to avoid them.
If you’re planning to ship a car, understanding these patterns can help you steer clear of common auto transport mistakes and make the entire process far less stressful.
The process of shipping a car across the United States often ends in incredible frustration and financial loss for many people. This is evident from countless posts on Reddit and the Better Business Bureau (BBB) warning others by sharing their painful stories.
A common phrase seen in these Reddit car shipping threads is “I wish I knew this before I booked. In this guide, we will translate those hard-learned lessons into tales of precaution. By analysing such complaints left by real consumers, we will identify common industry patterns that will help you make smarter decisions in the future.
Falling victim to common auto transport mistakes can lead to significant stress and financial losses. This is why avoiding car shipping fraud by learning how to spot common car shipping red flags is important for safeguarding your vehicle’s transportation.
This guide will help you enhance your intuition by identifying the most common mistakes that can occur during vehicle transport and how to avoid them.
How to chose a quote. (My 2 cents)
byu/GHoSTyaiRo inAutoTransport
The most commonly reported consumer error on public forums is the bait-and-switch that occurs when finding the cheapest quote. In many cases, a broker offers a rate that is considerably lower than that of their competitors. They secure a deposit from the user, but then fail to find a single carrier that can honor that low price.
This results in a last-minute demand for more money, often when the shipper is at their most vulnerable. Imagine your car being already loaded or you moving under a tight deadline, and your broker starts demanding a higher price for the transport.
Multiple posts on Reddit forums show that this is a fairly common tactic used in car shipping scams. It is specifically designed to lure customers with a cheaper cost before increasing it at the last possible moment.
Vet your transport companies!
byu/HillbettyGilligan inAutoTransport
Every legitimate carrier currently operating in the U.S. must have active Department of Transportation (DOT) and Motor Carrier (MC) numbers issued by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA). Handing your vehicle to a company without verifying this information is like giving your car keys to a stranger on the street.
In our research, we have found that BBB complaints in auto transport are filled with cases in which users failed to verify the DOT/MC numbers of their transport brokers. Since these unverified entities usually lack proper insurance as well, you are likely to face significant charges in case of any damage to your vehicle during transit.
Thankfully, there is an easy solution to prevent this problem. Just take 5 minutes to check your provider on the free FMCSA SAFER website to ensure your broker has the necessary credentials.
At faults cargo insurance is making me pay their $1000 deductible
byu/SilentInfluence7 inAutoTransport
Many users report frequent disputes with their carriers refusing damage claims to their vehicle, stating the damage as “pre-existing” or not covered under their policy. This is why it is very important to read the fine print of your insurance and verify its coverage.
Even though federal law requires minimum insurance for such businesses, their coverage limits are often outdated for modern vehicles. To avoid paying for transit damages, you should request and review the carrier’s insurance certificate properly. These include verifying specifics on liability and cargo limits and matching them with your vehicle’s current value.
Do not accept verbal assurances from the broker. Make sure you have written proof of your coverage specifics, especially if you are shipping a luxury, classic, or exotic car.
Advice ? – Car damaged during transport and concealed / Montway ISVN
byu/rynoranger inAutoTransport
The Bill of Lading (BOL) is your legal contract with the broker and your vehicle’s condition report. One of the worst mistakes a shipper can make is signing a clean BOL without noting down every detail of a scratch, dent, or chip. Inspecting and addressing any previous scratches or dents to the receiver of the vehicle is crucial. This ensures that damages incurred during transit are attributable to and payable by the broker itself.
There are many stories on Reddit car shipping forums where users detail disputes about how a new dent appeared on their vehicle upon delivery. But since the shipper had no prior proof that the dent wasn’t there before shipping, the cost of fixing it fell on the user.
To avoid this mistake, it is essential to take timestamped photos and videos of your vehicle from all angles before pickup. In case of vehicle damage during transit, this photographic evidence can prove invaluable.
Advice on delays
byu/sadboysdontdie inAutoTransport
It is important to understand that auto transport is a logistics business, not a standalone courier service. Most carriers combine multiple shipments on the same route. There are also factors like weather, traffic, and mechanical issues that are inherent to cross-country travel across the US.
Thus, expecting a carrier to hit the precise one-hour window for pickup or delivery will often lead to frustration. This is precisely why reputable companies frequently provide an estimated pickup window of up to 3 days. Always plan for delays, and understand that expecting complete precision over your timeline will usually lead to stress and disappointment.
Why Shipping in December Costs More Than July
byu/TheLoganReyes inAutoTransport
Research in the US auto transport market shows that the industry is highly seasonal and prices spike during demand periods like summer moves and the “snowbird” migration from northern to southern states during the fall. Ironically, shipping from very low-demand or rural areas can also be very expensive due to a lack of carrier traffic.
This shows a clear pattern you can use to ensure the lowest possible pricing for your auto transportation. Ignoring this pattern can lead to incurring higher costs and longer logistical timings for your transportation.
The key is to plan your shipment in accordance with these patterns. For example, planning a shipment from Michigan to Florida in October will require a completely different budget than a Texas-to-California shipment in February. Demand and weather conditions can completely change your pricing and carrier availability.
Broker asking for deposit that’s half the quote amount before I’ve signed a contract.
by inAutoTransport
Many established carriers will usually require payment upon delivery, not before it. If your carrier demands a large cash deposit or full payment before your pickup, it can be a major red flag for a potential car shipping scam. Once you pay the entire amount, your leverage is completely gone.
Thus, you should always defer the payment until after the transport is received. The recommended payment method is to use a credit card to provide greater security against such car shipping scams. It has purchase protection, and your credit card provider can make sure the service is completed before releasing the funds.
PSA: Broker making false claims after honest review about poor communication
byu/retlehs inAutoTransport
If a broker is hard to reach or very vague in their explanations before your booking, your situation is unlikely to improve after you pay. Multiple BBB complaints in auto transport forums clearly state that unanswered calls and emails are a widespread issue.
Furthermore, if a contract doesn’t explicitly state specific timeframes, fees, costs, or damage claims, you are liable to pay hefty charges on top of the broker’s claims. This is why it is important to partner with a broker that promotes clear and proactive communication. Your written contracts should be detailed, and the absence of clear communication or contracts should always be a deal-breaker.
If you are not researching a company online in this digital age on your own, you are making a grave mistake. Beyond the FMCSA, make sure you complete a thorough check about the carrier online, including:
Remember, a few negative reviews of the broker are regular, but a dozen reviews citing the same issue are problematic. Always look for patterns in the reviews, as recurring issues such as unfair pricing or undisclosed damage can indicate genuine concerns.
PSA: Broker making false claims after honest review about poor communication
byu/retlehs inAutoTransport
Selecting the right transport for your vehicle is critical to ensure the safety of your shipment. While open transport is usually safe for most daily drivers, transportation of high-value or exotic cars can benefit from enclosed trailers. This will help prevent road debris and weather-related damage to your luxury vehicles.
On the other hand, paying a premium for an enclosed transport that you don’t need is also an unnecessary expense. Assess your vehicle’s value and choose only the transport method that best suits your vehicle.
One thing to understand about the errors above is that they are not random mistakes. They are a result of an industry that suffers from a very low barrier to entry for brokers. This exposes customers in the auto transport industry to common broker scams.
One of the most common car shipping scams is the “book and pray” model, in which an unlicensed broker accepts a very low quote and then scrambles to find a carrier that can match it. This leads to issues like last-minute price hikes and the use of unsafe carriers for your vehicles. In each of these cases, the end customer is usually the most harmed by the broker’s unethical tactics.
Moreover, the industry’s shift to online platforms has only increased these risks. Brokers regularly create fake carrier profiles and generate fraudulent reviews to trick customers into choosing them, offering cheap pricing as a lure. Risks like these have made doing proper due diligence more critical than ever.
At Haulin.AI, we have built our platform to eliminate the vulnerabilities listed above systematically. Our sole mission is to change the auto transport industry for the better by making transparency and reliability core tenets of our platform.
Using sophisticated AI-driven technologies, we enforce a higher standard of service with a protection that reliably serves our customers.
Some of the best features of Haulin.AI include:
Shipping your expensive car should never feel like a gamble. The common auto transport mistakes listed above show that there are forums full of predictable, avoidable errors. By recognising these car shipping red flags, you can ensure you make informed decisions about your auto transport needs.
Haulin.ai is the perfect partner in making such informed decisions. Combining innovative AI technology with a dedicated commitment to always put our customers first, we deliver the car shipping experience you expect and deserve.
Move beyond broker scams and surprises by getting:
With Haulin.ai, your vehicle’s journey is always in capable hands, from pickup to delivery.
Haulin.ai doesn’t just automate — it personalizes. Get instant, route-specific quotes, real-time tracking updates, and smart scheduling that adapts to you — all backed by 24/7 customer support powered by AI and advanced technology.
Mon – Sat: 09.00AM – 05.00PM
Sun: Close
